Introduction

Preservation of the quality and extension of shelf-life stability of perishable products such as seafood is one of the most important factors throughout the seafood production process.1 The spoilage in seafood is caused by reactions related to the enzymatic activities of the own, oxidation of lipids and metabolic activities of microorganisms. The fact that seafood contain high nitrogen compounds and low acidity are factors that accelerate spoilage.2 With seafood processing technology, this quality loss is prevented, ensuring food safety, meeting customer demands in a sustainable way, and preventing food waste by extending shelf life.3

Traditional methods such as curing, drying, fermentation, smoking, chilling and freezing used in the processing of seafood have disadvantages such as limited shelf life and protection, changes in sensory properties and high energy requirement. With the developments in technology and Industry 4.0, applications such as cold plasma, radiofrequency, ultrasound, microwave and smart packaging will be new technologies that are being used in the processing of seafood. The demand for natural preservatives and ecologically friendly implementations in these the conservation processes has gradually expanded as consumer awareness has grown. This increase has accelerated the spread of environmentally friendly practices with the emergence of new packaging technologies.4 Ozone is one of the most sustainable disinfection applications thanks to its cost-effective production,5 with no environmental impact.6 Ozone is currently widely used in many fields such as aquaculture, livestock and vegetable-fruit production and processing7. To explain the mechanism of action of ozone on the pathogen, it oxidizes the cell wall and the membranes in its structure, disrupts the structural integrity of the cell, and then inactivates the DNA by destroying it. Studies on the processing of seafood have shown that the use of ozone extends the shelf life of the product by lowering the number of germs on the product’s surfaces.7 It has been reported that this increase may extend up to 2 to 5 days, depending on the application dose, duration, ambient temperature, method and the product to which the application is made.8 It has been reported in some studies that the use of ozone in seafood products has an important effect on shelf life and quality preservation. Gelman et al.7 studied the quality changes in tilapia fish stored at 0 and 5˚C for 30 days and reported that 6 ppm ozone application significantly increased the shelf life of tilapia fish stored at 0˚C. In another study, Dehkordi and Zokaie9 reported that the shelf life of ozone-treated trout was extended from 4 days to 6 days. Nerantzaki et al.10 evaluated the quality changes in rainbow trout which were vacuum packed as a whole and stored at 4˚C for 15 days with 0.6 and 0.4 mg/l and 60- and 90-minutes ozone treatment. According to the results of microbiological and sensory analysis, it was reported that the shelf life of rainbow trout treated with ozone for 60 and 90 minutes was 10 and 12 days.

Meagre (Argyrosomus regius) has a high market value due to its attractive appearance, high nutritional value and selenium, texture suitable for processing and consumption, low-fat content, deliciousness and high processing efficiency.11 It is expected that meagre cultivation will increase gradually, especially in European countries and Türkiye (4771 tonnes in 2022, TUİK12), thanks to the existing demand and the advantages it has in cultivation such as rapid growth, good feed intake and late sexual maturation.13

In the frame of the cited literature, the aim of this study is to determine the effect of aqueous ozone (1ppm) applied for variable time durations (15 and 30 minutes) on the microbiological and sensory quality together with the color changes of vacuum-packed meagre fillets stored at +2°C for for 12 days.

Materials and Methods

Sample preparation

Whole meagre samples (at total 20 fish) with an average weight of 305.37±30.96 were obtained from a local fish market. Specimens were placed in Styrofoam boxes with ice cover and immediately transported to the laboratory in 15 min. Upon arrival at the laboratory whole meagre were washed and filleted. The average weight of the fillets was 123.30±23.28 The fillets were randomly divided into 3 groups. The first group was marked as the control ( C ), the second group indicates the fillets that are treated for 15 min (O-15) and the last group stands for the group treated for 30 min (O-30) in aqueous ozone. The application times considered to have best reduction in the numbers of microorganisms and prevent odor formation14,15 Following to the ozone treatment fillets were individually vacuum-packed with low-density pouches. Fillets were stored at +2°C for 12 days. Microbiological, color and sensory analyses were performed periodically. In each sampling day, repetitions for microbiological and sensory analysis were consisted of 2, while color analyses were performed from 10 repetitions.

Aqueous ozone treatment

In the study, ozone applied by dissolving in water (aqueous ozone) was produced using an ozone generator (EDF A-25 model, EDF Industrial Ozone Systems, Turkey). The generator has a 25 g/hour capacity and uses corona discharge mechanism. Ozone, which comes out of the generator in gas form, was dissolved in water by using a water pump with a venturi and given to a plastic container filled with 20 liters of sterile pure water in which the fillets were immersed for 15 and 30 min. The ozone level in the water was 1 ppm (875 mV) which is the maximum capacity of the generator, and the water pump was used to process the fillets in a uniform manner. The ozone level in the water was measured and monitored with the ADWA ORP/Redox Meters throughout the entire process, including the preparation of the washing water and the washing of the fillets.

Microbiological analysis

Ten grams of sample was aseptically obtained on sampling days from control and aqueous ozone-treated and vacuum-packed meagre fillets. Samples were homogenized in 90 ml buffered peptone water (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) for 3 min. From the homogenized sample, serial dilutions were prepared. The counts of microorganisms namely Total Mesophilic Aerobic Bacteria (TMAB), Total Psychrophilic Aerobic Bacteria (TPAB), Pseudomonas sp. and Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) were determined in accordance with the method described by Sallam.16 Plate count Agar (PCA, Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) was used for the enumeration of TMAB and TPAB. LAB was enumerated on De Man Rogosa and Sharp (MRS) agar (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and Pseudomonas sp. was quantified on Cephaloridin-Fucidin-Cetrimide (CFC) agar with CFC supplement (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) with spread plate method. Microorganisms were incubated at 30, 4 and 25˚C for 2, 10 and 2 days for TMAB, TPAB, Pseudomonas sp. and LAB, respectively.

Color analysis

Color measurements of the samples were performed using a 3NH color meter (Shenzen ThreeNH Tech. China). Ten different measurements were taken from each fillet. The parameter L were used for brightness, a for red-green and b for yellow-blue. Hue and chroma was calculated based on the Eqs. 1 and 2, respectively.

Chroma=(a 2+b 2)1/2

Hue=Arctan(b/a)

Sensory analysis

Sensory analysis of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets was carried out according to the method described by Hernández et al.17 Raw and skinned meagre fillets were evaluated by 4 trained panelists for the appearance of the flesh and skin, odor and texture and the attributes are given in Table 1. Samples were placed on the bench in the laboratory free from any odor source to prevent odor contamination during the analysis. Additionally, samples were analyzed in terms of color changes under the natural day light. The samples were considered inconsumable when the total scores of sensory analyses reached 15 out of 30.

Table 1.Attributes of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets
Parameters Attributes Score
Skin Color 1-5 (intensity)
Flesh Color 1-5 (intensity)
Muscle 1-5 (adhereness)
Shine 1-5 (brightness)
Odor 1-5 (fresh – putrefied)
Texture 1-5 (elasticity)

Statistical analysis

The comparison of the mean scores to the corresponding analysis was performed in duplicate. The results were expressed as mean ± standard deviation. The significance of the mean scores was analyzed by analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Tukey’s HSD test was applied as the post-hoc tests. A statistical package (SPSS Inc. Chicago, USA) was used to for the calculation of significant differences between groups. The confidence intervals were adjusted to p<0.05 level.

Results

Microbiological changes

Microbiological changes in vacuum-packed meagre fillets treated with gaseous ozone for different application times during storage at +2 ˚C are shown in Figure 1a-d. The initial Pseudomonas sp., TMAB, LAB and TPAB counts of the C, O-15 and O-30 groups were 4.00±0.03, 3.80±0.08 and 3.35±0.17 log cfu/g; 4.08±0.01, 3.90±0.02 and 3.71±0.02; 2.14±0.10, 1.23±0.33 and 1.15±0.21 and 4.01±0.04, 3.95±0.02 and 3.79±0.11 log cfu/g, respectively. In all evaluated bacterial groups, an increase was observed for each group until the end of the storage period and the increase in bacterial counts was found to be statistically significant (p<0.05). In this framework, although there were significant differences (p<0.05) between the groups in terms of Pseudomonas sp. and TMAB counts in ozone-treated samples on the first day of storage, there was no significant effect on LAB and TPAB counts (p>0.05).

Figure 1
Figure 1.Changes in microbial quality of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets. a) Pseudomonas sp., b) Mesophilic bacteria, c) LAB, d) Psychrophilic bacteria. Results were presented in log cfu/g mean ± SD.

However, at the end of the storage, substantial variations were noticed between the groups. The growth of Pseudomonas sp. and LAB in the O-30 group was significantly lower than the other groups (Figure 1a-d). On the other hand, TMAB counts revealed no significant variations between groups (p>0.05). Regarding TPAB counts, significant differences were observed between O-15 and O-30 groups and C group (p<0.05). All bacterial groups except Pseudomonas sp. of the O-30 group exceeded 7.00 log cfu/g. In the O-30 group, Pseudomonas sp. was determined as 6.88±0.15 log cfu/g on the 12th day. On the last day of storage, the number of Pseudomonas sp. TMAB, LAB and TPAB were determined to be 7.84±0.08, 8.06±0.30, 7.38±0.12 and 8.32±0. 10 log cfu/g for the C group, 7.50±0.28, 7.65±0.06, 7.30±0.00 and 7.86±0.12 log cfu/g for the O-15 group and 6.88±0.15, 7.03±0.61, 7.00±0.00 and 7.65±0.06 log cfu/g for the O-30 group.

Sensory changes

The sensory changes in vacuum-packed meagre fillets treated with ozone for different periods of time are given in Figure 2 a-g. Panelists examined the skin and flesh color, muscle, brightness, odor and texture changes of the samples during 12 days of storage. Skin and flesh color parameter showed a notable increase in all samples on the last day of storage (P<0.05), but no influential difference was observed between the groups for skin and flesh color (p>0.05) (Fig. 2 a-b). Demerit points, which characterize the muscle structure of the samples, increased according to the storage time. Significant differences were determined for the control group on days 8 and 12, and for the O-15 group on day 12 compared to the initial values (p<0.05). No significant increase was observed for the O-30 group, depending on the storage time (p>0.05). There was no statistical difference between the samples during 12 days of storage (p>0.05) (Fig. 2c). The brightness increased considerably with time (p<0.05). Major differences (p<0.05) were seen in ozone-treated samples compared to the control group (Fig. 2d). The odor parameter showed a substantial alterations from the first days of storage for the C group (p<0.05).

Figure 2
Figure 2.Sensory changes of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets a) skin color, b) flesh color, c) muscle, d) brightness, e) odor, f) texture, and g) total points.

Among the ozone-treated groups, the O-15 group exhibited a significant increase from the 4th day of storage and the O-30 group showed a meaningful increase from the 8th day of storage (p<0.05) (Fig. 2e). The last parameter that increased based on the storage time was texture and the change of demerit points was determined increased on the 12th day in the control group and on the 8th day in the O-15 group. In the O-30 group, the change with storage time was not statistically significant (p>0.05) (Fig 2f). The changes in total demerit points, which give the sum of the variables evaluated by the panelists, are given in Fig 2g. In total, out of 30 demerit points, on the last day of storage, the control group had 18, the O-15 group was 16.25 and the O-30 group had 14.75 points. There was a notable increase in the total points of all groups according to the storage time (p<0.05), but there was no significant difference between the groups at the end of the storage time (p>0.05). It was observed that the odor and texture parameters approached the highest score of 5 and the other parameters increased up to 3 when the sensory changes occurred during 12 days of storage in the ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets. Regarding the total points, it was observed that none of the groups reached the highest value of 30. However, it was determined that the acceptability limit of 15 was exceeded by the control and O-15 groups, and the O-30 group was very close to this value at 14.75. In the determination of these data, the storage time in which the quality of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets could be stored under chilled conditions at 2.00 °C was determined as 8 days for the control and O-15 group and 12 days for the O-30 group.

Color changes

The color changes in the ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets during storage are given in Table 2. Significant variations (p<0.05) were found between the chromatic parameters (L-lightness, a-redness-greenness, and b blueness-yellowness) between the groups only on the 12th day of storage (p<0.05). While lightness increased in C group samples (p>0. 05), no increase was observed in the O-15 and O-30 groups (p>0.05).

Table 2.Color values of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets*
Sample Storage time (days) L a b Chroma Hue angle
Control 0 9.47±0.95A -0.55±1.98A 2.72±2.19Aa 3.51±1.89Ab -0.75±0.74A
4 9.52±0.98A -0.66±2.08A 2.83±2.23Aa 3.88±1.38A -0.59±1.12A
8 10.61±1.15A -2.65±2.24A 5.24±2.69Aa 5.85±3.43A -0.89±0.75A
12 10.17±1.22Ab -1.84±2.42Ab 4.33±2.84Aa 5.33±2.78Ab -0.90±0.49A
O-15 0 10.03±1.81A -1.64±3.76A 4.11±4.15Aa 6.45±2.44Ab -0.95±0.32A
4 10.87±1.41A -2.91±2.33A 5.45±2.81Aa 6.29±3.47A -0.87±0.76A
8 11.13±1.40A -3.84±2.71A 6.61±3.33Aa 7.70±4.19A -1.12±0.18A
12 10.93±1.42Aab -3.15±2.52Aab 5.76±2.98Aa 6.89±3.34Aab -0.95±0.38A
O-30 0 11.10±2.70A -3.66±5.45A 5.07±7.74Aa 10.13±4.27Aa -0.58±0.75A
4 10.34±1.65A -2.26±3.24A 4.33±3.42Aa 5.82±4.38A -0.44±0.96A
8 10.73±0.83A -3.09±1.63A 5.63±1.96Aa 6.45±2.49A -1.10±0.11A
12 11.91±1.83Aa -4.86±3.03Aa 7.92±3.78Aa 9.46±4.48Aa -0.86±0.46A

*Different superscript lower-case letters in the same column represents statistically significant differences among the groups and different superscripts capital letters indicate statistical differences among storage time (p<0.05)

For a parameter, it was observed that the redness value of the samples in the O-15 and 30 groups increased compared to the control group and statistically significant differences were determined on the 12th day of storage (p<0. 05). In the b value, which indicates the blueness-yellowness, no significant change was found in the groups during storage (p>0.05). However, differences were observed in the chroma value between the samples on the first and last day of storage (p<0.05). In this context, it was observed that the chroma value of the ozone-treated samples was higher than the control group (p<0.05). The Hue angle did not show a significant difference between the groups during storage (p>0.05).

Discussion

ICMSF has determined consumable limits for the microbial load of seafood for human consumption. In this context, the maximum number of total mesophilic bacteria that can be found in good quality seafood was reported as 5.70 log cfu/g and the acceptance limit for consumption as 7.00 log cfu/g.18,19 In this context, the total mesophilic bacteria count determined for all groups were below the limits determined by ICMSF (Fig. 1b) and in this scope, it is seen that the meagre fillets are of good quality. It was observed that ozone treatment significantly reduced the number of mesophilic bacteria in vacuum-packed meagre (p<0.05). Similar to our study, researchers examined the quality changes that occurred during the storage of Pacific white shrimp treated with minimal ozone on ice. According to the results of the study, the initial total viable count (TVC) of shrimp treated for 1 minute at a concentration of 100 mg/h was reported as 4.44 and 4.01 log cfu/g after ozone treatment.20 Psychrophilic bacteria are microorganisms that are able to proliferate in low temperatures and can be found in almost every food and can pose a threat to food safety in some cases along with food spoilage.21 In the changes of the total number of psychrophilic bacteria during cold storage in vacuum-packed meagre fillets treated with ozone for different periods of time, it was observed that ozone treatment did not have a significant effect on the total number of psychrophilic bacteria in the samples on the first day of storage (p>0.05) (Fig. 1d). However, significant increases in the total number of psychrophilic bacteria of each group were determined depending on the storage time (p<0. 05). At the end of the storage period, total psychrophilic bacteria counts were significantly higher in the control group than in the ozone-treated O-15 and O-30 groups (p<0.05). In a study, microbial and chemical quality changes in tiger groupers stored in slurry ice containing 0.1 mg/l ozone and 3.3% NaCl were investigated. The researchers reported that the number of psychrotrophic bacteria in ozone-treated slurry ice was significantly lower than in the control and NaCl-containing slurry ice samples. Furthermore, on the 20th day of storage, the researchers reported that the number of psychrotrophic bacteria in the ozone-containing group was significantly lower compared to the other groups.22 It is assumed that the results obtained in ozone-treated and vacuum-packed meagre fillets have a repressive effect on the number of psychrophilic bacteria that cause spoilage in seafood.

Pseudomonas sp. is a psychrotrophic, non-fermentative, aerobic bacterium that causes spoilage and thus quality losses in seafood.23 On the first day of storage, ozone treatment significantly lowered the counts of Pseudomonas sp. in the O-30 group compared to the O-15 and control groups (p<0.05). The inhibitory effect of ozone treatment on the growth of Pseudomonas sp. in seafood was shown by Glatman et al.24 and in this context, the results were in agreement with that ozone treated vacuum packed meagre fillets. The researchers indicated that the shelf life of tilapia fish stored under chilled conditions increased by 40% at 0˚C and that this was due to the suppression of the growth of Pseudomonas sp. by ozone. However, the development of Pseudomonas sp. in ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets increased rapidly in all groups with time (p<0.05). At the end of the storage time, the number of Pseudomonas sp. was statistically significantly lower in the O-30 group than in the O-15 and control group (p<0.05) and it could be considered that the ozone treatment applied in the O-30 group suppressed the growth of Pseudomonas sp. In the study conducted by Lan et al.,25 it was reported that ozone application inhibited the growth of Pseudomonas sp. in seafood stored under cold conditions. The researchers examined the quality changes of ozonized slurry ice application in the cold chain cycle of large yellow croaker (Pseudosciaena crocea) and reported that ozonized slurry ice application significantly decreased the number of Pseudomonas sp. in the samples on the 21st day, the last day of storage. In our study, Pseudomonas sp. showed significant (p<0.05) growth at the end of the 12-day storage period in ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets. This growth is thought to be due to the fact that Pseudomonas sp. is a bacterium that causes spoilage in seafood26 and its initial number cannot be reduced enough to suspend its proliferation27 but rather ozone treatment aids to slow down the growth of the bacteria (Fig 1a).

On the first day of storage, LAB counts in vacuum-packed meagre fillets treated at different duration were 2.07±0.10 log cfu/g for the control group, 1.23±0.33 log cfu/g for the O-15 group and 1.15±0.21 log cfu/g for the O-30 group (p>0.05) (Fig 1c). LAB counts of each group increased significantly according to the storage time and the highest was determined in the control group. On the last day of the storage period, the 12th day, significant differences were determined between the O-30 group and the O-15 and control groups (p<0.05). In this context, it is considered that ozone application is effective on LAB in vacuum-packed meagre fillets of the O-30 group. Lower LAB counts were reported for ozone water treated air, vacuum and modified atmosphere-packed soft shell mud crab (Scylla serrata Forskal) stored under refrigerated temperatures.28 Researchers were reported that the shelf life of soft-shell mud crab treated with 1.0 ppm ozone for 20 min and packed in 80% CO2+20% NO2 was significantly increased and the counts of LAB ozone-treated samples were not exceeded 6.87 log cfu/g. In another study conducted with sea bream fillets, similar to this study, it was reported that LAB counts decreased by 0.10 ± 0.01 log cfu/g after 640 ppm ozone concentration was applied at 25˚C for 30 minutes.29 From this perspective, it was concluded that ozone treatments of meagre fillets are compatible with different seafood products given in the literature in terms of LAB numbers and ozone application slows down LAB growth.

Studies have shown that ozone application in seafood extends shelf life and preserves sensory quality. Ling et al.30 examined the changes occurring during the storage of ultra-high pressure combined with ozone water in catfish fillets under refrigerator conditions. The researchers reported that total demerit points increased in all groups during storage. However, they reported that ozone water and UHP reached the threshold value on the 9th day of storage. In another study, researchers examined the effect of gaseous ozone application on the quality changes occurring in salmon stored under chilled conditions. The researchers reported that the sensory threshold was exceeded on the 8th day of storage in the control group salmon, but ozone-treated samples were still consumable.31 In another study with stripped red mullet, researchers examined the quality changes that occurred during the storage of stripped red mullet at 1.°C with the combination of ozone and modified atmosphere package. The researchers reported that the control group samples reached the maximum 13 demerit points on the 12th day and the ozone MAP and MAP samples reached the maximum demerit point on the 15th day. They reported that the control group reached the acceptable limit on the 7th day and the ozone MAP and MAP group on the 10th day.32 Additionally, the shelf life extension by 2 days in ozonated trout9 and ozonated vacuum packed whole rainbow trout by 4 days10 has been reported. Within the framework of these data, according to the sensory values, it was determined that the shelf life of vacuum-packed meagre fillets was extended 4 days depending on the ozone application time and was similar to that of other studies.

It was observed that the L value was higher in ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets compared to the control group. This is thought to be due to the bleaching effect of ozone.30 Similarly, in a study conducted on minimally ozone-treated fresh shrimp, 100mg/h ozone-treated samples were stored in ice for 10 days. The researchers reported that the L values of minimal ozone-treated fresh shrimp on the 10th day of storage were higher than the control group, although they did not report a statistically significant difference.20 In the parameter a where the redness-greenness value was determined, it was observed that the redness value of O-15 and O-30 groups was higher. The change of a parameter according to the storage time did not show significant differences (p>0.05), but differences were determined between the groups on the 12th day of storage (p<0.05). a values have been reported to be an important parameter in terms of color evaluation in tilapia.33,34 However, when evaluated in terms of meagre, it was observed that a value differed between the groups only on the 12th day. In this framework, it was observed that ozone treatment did not show a significant change in vacuum-packed meagre. No significant change was observed in the b values of ozone-treated vacuum-packed meagre fillets between storage time and groups (p>0.05). However, it was observed that b values were higher in ozone-treated samples compared to the control group. This was observed to be due to the increase in yellowness value in ozone-treated fillets and it is thought that ozone application shows an oxidative effect.34 Similarly, De Mendonça Silva and Gonçalves34 examined the effect of aqueous ozone application on microbial and physico-chemical properties in Nile tilapia processing and reported that b values in ozone-treated groups were generally higher than non-ozone treated groups and this was due to oxidation in lipids and pigments.

In conclusion, microbiological and sensory quality and color changes in vacuum-packed meagre fillets during 12 days of storage at +2°C were investigated in this study. It was observed that ozone treatment preserved the quality changes of vacuum-packed meagre fillets. This study also showed that the growth of TMAB, Pseudomonas sp., LAB and TPAB was slower in ozone treated samples compared to the control group. In addition, Ozone-treatment preserved the sensory parameters of the meagre fillets and did not cause a significant difference in the color changes of the samples. Moreover, it was revealed in this study that the shelf life was prolonged by 4 days and 30 min of application time was found to be more effective compared to those of control and 15 min in ozone-treated vacuum-packaged meagre fillets.


Acknowledgments

The authors thank the staff of the Eğirdir Fisheries Faculty for their valuable help in the laboratory experiments and EDF Industrial Ozone Systems to provide the ozone generator.

Authors’ Contribution using CRediT

Conceptualization: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Methodology: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Formal Analysis: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Investigation: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Writing – original draft: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Writing – review & editing: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Funding acquisition: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Resources: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Equal), Muhammet H. KAYHAN (Equal). Supervision: Ismail Y. GENÇ (Lead).